35 important comments by critics on William Shakespeare, which will be helpful for the UP TGT exam:
1-5: Early Critics (16th-17th Century)
1. Ben Jonson – "He was not of an age, but for all time!"
2. Francis Meres (1598) – "Shakespeare among the English is the most excellent in both comedy and tragedy."
3. John Dryden – "Shakespeare was the man who of all modern, and perhaps ancient poets, had the largest and most comprehensive soul."
4. Alexander Pope – "Shakespeare is the poet of nature, able to depict human passions more vividly than any other."
5. Samuel Pepys (1662, on ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream’) – "It is the most insipid, ridiculous play that I ever saw."
6-10: 18th Century Critics
6. Dr. Samuel Johnson – "Shakespeare holds up to his readers a faithful mirror of manners and life."
7. Nicholas Rowe – "Shakespeare excelled in the boldness of his imagination and originality of expression."
8. Joseph Addison – "Shakespeare was a great genius, but he wrote without method or plan."
9. Edward Young – "He had the power to see into the very heart of human nature."
10. Voltaire (critical view) – "Shakespeare’s genius is powerful, but his works lack refinement."
11-15: 19th Century Romantic and Victorian Critics
11. Samuel Taylor Coleridge – "The characters of Shakespeare are not mere creations of fancy but real human beings."
12. William Hazlitt – "Shakespeare was the greatest genius of all time; his plays embody the universal truths of humanity."
13. Charles Lamb – "No writer has ever understood human emotions as deeply as Shakespeare."
14. Victor Hugo – "Shakespeare is the greatest poet that ever lived, a universe in himself."
15. Matthew Arnold – "Shakespeare remains the summit of literature, towering over all others."
16-20: 20th Century Critics
16. T.S. Eliot – "Dante and Shakespeare divide the world between them. There is no third."
17. G. Wilson Knight – "Shakespeare’s plays are more than literature; they are a philosophy of life."
18. A.C. Bradley – "Shakespearean tragedy shows the ruin of something great and beautiful."
19. L.C. Knights – "Shakespeare does not moralize; he dramatizes human experience."
20. E.M.W. Tillyard – "Shakespeare reflects the Elizabethan world order in his plays."
21-25: Modern and Postmodern Critics
21. Harold Bloom – "Shakespeare invented the human as we know it."
22. Stephen Greenblatt – "Shakespeare is the most remarkable storyteller in history, shaping cultural narratives even today."
23. Frank Kermode – "Shakespeare speaks to each age in a voice that is uniquely its own."
24. Jonathan Bate – "Shakespeare’s plays continue to redefine literature and drama across cultures."
25. Stanley Wells – "Shakespeare’s works are endlessly interpretable, which is why they endure."
26-30: Shakespeare’s Universality
26. Goethe – "Shakespeare’s world is so vast that he understands all people, past, present, and future."
27. Hegel – "Shakespeare’s drama represents the complete dialectic of human freedom and fate."
28. Jorge Luis Borges – "All literature, in some way, returns to Shakespeare."
29. Isaiah Berlin – "Shakespeare embodies the paradoxes of human nature like no other writer."
30. F.R. Leavis – "Shakespeare’s characters have a life beyond the text."
31-35: Critiques and Dissenting Opinions
31. George Bernard Shaw – "Shakespeare is a great writer, but he is vastly overrated."
32. Leo Tolstoy – "Shakespeare’s plays lack depth; they do not provide real moral lessons."
33. Virginia Woolf – "If Shakespeare had a sister with his talent, she would never have been allowed to write."
34. Terry Eagleton – "Shakespeare’s plays are products of ideology, reinforcing power structures."
35. Sigmund Freud – "Shakespeare understood the unconscious mind long before modern psychology."
These critical opinions cover Shakespeare’s literary genius, influence, and some critiques, making them valuable references for exams and literary discussions.
No comments:
Post a Comment