Early Prose Writers: Sir Thomas More, John Foxe

Early Prose Writers: Sir Thomas More and John Foxe

The development of English prose during the Renaissance period marks a critical evolution in the literary history of England. Among the earliest and most influential prose writers were Sir Thomas More and John Foxe. Both men not only contributed significantly to the prose tradition in English literature but also played pivotal roles in shaping the religious, political, and social discourses of their time. While their styles and purposes differed, their works remain central to understanding the transformation of English prose in the 16th century.

Sir Thomas More (1478–1535): Humanist and Political Thinker

Sir Thomas More was a key figure of the English Renaissance and a leading exponent of Christian humanism. He was not only a lawyer and statesman but also a profound thinker and writer whose influence extended far beyond his lifetime. More’s prose is marked by clarity, irony, and a deep moral concern, which is most evident in his landmark work, Utopia (1516).

Utopia and Its Legacy

Utopia, originally written in Latin, was translated into English later and stands as one of the earliest examples of English prose fiction. The work presents an imaginary island where social, political, and economic structures differ drastically from those in contemporary Europe. Through this imagined society, More critiques the injustices and corruption of his own time, especially those related to governance, wealth distribution, and the legal system.

The narrative is presented through a dialogue between More himself and a fictional character, Raphael Hythlodaeus. This dialogic structure reflects the influence of classical models, particularly Plato’s dialogues, and allows More to explore conflicting viewpoints. The prose style in Utopia is elegant and rational, often interspersed with satire, which was a hallmark of Renaissance humanist writing.

More’s contribution to English prose lies not only in the content but also in the stylistic advancements he introduced. He moved English prose closer to the Latin rhetorical tradition, bringing in balance, periodicity, and a persuasive tone that would influence generations of English prose writers.

Other Writings

In addition to Utopia, More wrote a number of theological and polemical works, such as A Dialogue Concerning Heresies and The Confutation of Tyndale's Answer. These works defended Catholic orthodoxy against the emerging Protestant Reformation and were written in English, demonstrating his commitment to reaching a wider audience. Though more polemical in tone, these writings still reflect More's intellectual rigor and mastery of prose.

His martyrdom in 1535, following his refusal to endorse Henry VIII’s separation from the Catholic Church, solidified his legacy as a man of principle and faith. In 1935, he was canonized by the Catholic Church, and today he is remembered both as a saint and a scholar.

John Foxe (1516–1587): Historian and Protestant Apologist

In contrast to More’s Catholic humanism, John Foxe emerged as a powerful voice of the English Protestant Reformation. A historian and martyrologist, Foxe is best known for his monumental work Actes and Monuments (commonly known as Foxe’s Book of Martyrs), first published in 1563. This work, written in English, represents one of the earliest and most influential pieces of English historical prose.

Actes and Monuments: A Protestant Epic

Foxe’s Actes and Monuments is a vast historical compilation that documents the sufferings of Protestants under Catholic persecution, especially during the reign of Mary I. The work was intended not just as a chronicle of events but as a moral and religious guide. It served both a historical and propagandistic purpose, reinforcing Protestant values and portraying Catholicism as a persecuting force.

Foxe’s prose is vigorous, emotive, and often polemical. His narratives are rich with dramatic episodes of martyrdom, trial, and suffering, intended to stir the reader’s emotions and affirm the righteousness of the Protestant cause. The use of plain, direct language made the work accessible to a wide readership, which was crucial in an age when literacy was expanding.

One of the most distinctive features of Foxe’s writing is his use of eyewitness accounts and documentary evidence. Though often criticized for partiality and exaggeration, Foxe’s methodology marked a step forward in historical writing, emphasizing the importance of source material and narrative coherence.

Influence and Legacy

Foxe’s Book of Martyrs became one of the most influential books in English Protestant households, second only to the Bible in its readership. It shaped the English Protestant identity for generations and played a major role in the collective memory of religious persecution. The book was even ordered to be kept in churches by royal injunctions, which ensured its widespread availability.

Foxe’s work also contributed to the development of English prose in its vernacular, documentary style. His commitment to plain English, combined with vivid narrative detail, paved the way for later historians and chroniclers. Though not always praised for literary finesse, Foxe’s prose was a powerful tool for ideological persuasion and historical reflection.

Comparison and Conclusion

Sir Thomas More and John Foxe represent two poles of the English Reformation: Catholic conservatism and Protestant reformism. While More’s prose is marked by classical elegance, moral philosophy, and intellectual dialogue, Foxe’s writing is characterized by emotional appeal, religious fervor, and historical documentation.

Both writers contributed to the growth of English prose in significant ways. More elevated the intellectual and stylistic standards of English prose, introducing sophisticated argumentation and irony. Foxe, on the other hand, demonstrated the power of English prose as a tool for mass communication, religious instruction, and historical narrative.

Their works also reflect the complex interplay of religion, politics, and literature in 16th-century England. More’s Utopia remains a cornerstone of political philosophy and Renaissance thought, while Foxe’s Actes and Monuments stands as a foundational text of English Protestant history.

Together, they exemplify the diversity and richness of early English prose writing, bridging the gap between medieval forms and modern prose traditions. For students and scholars, the study of More and Foxe offers invaluable insights into the origins of English prose and the turbulent historical forces that shaped its evolution.

---